Treating Female Patients
Shaykh (Mufti) Muhammad Taqi Usmani (HA)
I am a Muslim doctor (male) in USA. Since Allah gave me hidayah, I have slowly endeavored to become a more practicing Muslim and try to remove any haram in my life. One big concern of mine at the moment is that as a Doctor in USA, it is very difficult to avoid female patients. Many times I find myself alone in consultation with a female patient, and then there's the examination. Is this allowed in Islam? Will I be committing a sin? Please advise me on this matter.
Shariah has allowed a male medical practitioner to treat female patients. In the course of treatment the necessary examination is also allowed. However, you should try to persuade the female patients to consult a female doctor but if no female doctor is available or is not relied upon by the patient, it is lawful to treat them by taking all precautionary measures to save yourself from being in total privacy with them as far as possible and from exceeding the steps necessary for treatment.
Albalagh Note: It should be remembered that a female patient has a right to ask to be treated by a female physician and she is encouraged to exercise that right to the maximum extent possible. Further, if out of necessity she has to be examined by a male physician then it is suggested that the examination be limited to the area necessary for the treatment. Maulana Ashraf Ali Thanvi suggested that she be covered in her dress and an opening be made into it to allow only the necessary area to be exposed.
Women Seeking Medical treatment from Male Doctors
Shaykh (Mufti) Muhammad ibn Adam al-Kawthari (HA)
Question: What are the guidelines in women seeking treatment from men doctors? Is it permissible to visit a male doctor when a female doctor is available, especially when one may have to expose the Awra?
In the name of Allah, Most Compassionate, Most Merciful,
In the situation where a Muslim female is in need of medical treatment, the endeavour should be that she is treated by a female medical doctor, preferably a Muslim. If a female practitioner is:
1Easily available,
2One is satisfied and content with her medical treatment,
3There is no other valid legal (shar'i) excuse for not resorting to her treatment, then in such a case, it would not be permissible to seek the medication of a male doctor, rather, the illness must be treated by a qualified female doctor.
It is stated in al-Fatawa al-Hindiyya, a renowned Hanafi Fiqh reference:
"If a woman has a wound in a part of the body that is impermissible for a male to look at (m, meaning other than the face, hands & feet, for they are absolutely part of awra), it will be impermissible for her receive treatment from a male doctor, rather a female should be instructed to treat her. If a female expert is not available, neither is there a female who can be instructed to treat her... then in such a case it would be permitted for a male doctor to treat her, provided there is a genuine need. It will be necessary for her to cover other than the effected area, and he must lower his gaze as much as possible." (al-Fatawa al-Hindiyya, 5/330).
However, if the need is only for consultation or the medication is related to a part of the body that is not part of Awra, then it would be permissible to seek the treatment of a male doctor, although the treatment of a female doctor will still be preferable.
If the above-mentioned (3) points are not found, in that a medical female expert is not easily available, or if she is available, one is not content with her medication, or there is some other valid legal excuse, then in such a indispensable situation, it will be permissible to resort to the treatment of a male doctor, provided the male doctor only looks at (and handles) the effected area. The rest of the body of the female must remain covered.
Imam al-Haskafi (Allah have mercy on him) states:
"In the situation of a male doctor treating a female, he should only look at the effected area (m, whenever reasonably possible), for cases of need are restricted to the actual need. And it is preferable that the male doctor teaches and instructs a female in order to treat her, for looking (and treating) someone from the same gender is the lesser of two evils (m, i.e. when looking at parts of Awra)."
Imam Ibn Abidin (Allah have mercy on him) explains in his Radd al-Muhtar that, if the treatment is related to the private parts, then only in extreme situations will it be permitted for her to seek treatment of a male doctor. He states:
"If the treatment is on her private parts, then it is necessary that a female is instructed to treat her. If this is not possible and it is feared that the woman may perish or undergo unbearable pains, only then will it be permissible for a male to treat her." (See: Radd al-Muhtar ala al-Durr al-Mukhtar, 6/371).
The same has been mentioned in other Hanafi Fiqh references. See: Ibn Nujaym, Bahr al-Ra'iq, 8/192, Qadhikhan in his Fatawa, 3/409 & Bada'i al-Sana'i, 5/124.
Also, a Muslim doctor would be preferred over a non-Muslim for obvious reasons. However, if (once again) the three points are not met, then it would be permissible to seek the treatment of a non-Muslim doctor. Therefore the order in seeking medical treatment would be:
1Muslim female doctor
2Non-Muslim female doctor
3Muslim male doctor
4Non-Muslim male doctor
And in moving from one stage to another, the above three points should be kept in mind. The preference of a non-Muslim female doctor over a Muslim male doctor is due to the fact that, looking at the awra of someone from the same sex (as mentioned in Durr al-Mukhtar) is lesser of an evil. Also, the covering of one's nakedness in front of a (non-Mahram) male has been given more importance than covering in front of a non-Muslim female.
And Allah knows best
Muhammad ibn Adam al-Kawthari
No comments:
Post a Comment